Home » Court Restores United Methodist Church Name at CAC

Court Restores United Methodist Church Name at CAC

by newshubmag

ABUJA — The Federal High Court in Abuja has affirmed the United Methodist Church in Nigeria (UMCN) as the legally recognised name registered with the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC), bringing clarity to a contentious leadership and identity dispute within the church.

Delivering judgment on Monday, Justice Obiora Egwuatu ordered the CAC to immediately reverse the church’s name from Global Methodist Church in Nigeria (GMCN) back to UMCN. In addition, the court nullified the alteration of the church’s trustees, which had been effected on October 19, 2024, declaring the move unlawful, invalid, and void.

Furthermore, the court directed Zenith Bank Plc to grant members of the UMCN immediate access and control over all church accounts domiciled with the bank. This order effectively restores operational authority to the plaintiffs’ faction.

Justice Egwuatu held that the CAC failed to comply with the provisions of the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) in approving the name change. According to him, the process violated established legal procedures governing the alteration of an incorporated entity’s name and trustees.

He also emphasised that membership of any association, including a religious body, comes with an obligation to abide by its constitution. Therefore, he noted that individuals cannot unilaterally alter the identity of such an organisation under the guise of internal disagreements.

“A member of an association may choose to associate or disassociate, but cannot exit by changing the name of the association,” the judge ruled, citing established legal principles.

The case, marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1891/2024, was instituted by four members of the church—Benjamin Simon, Rev. Dr Eunice Iliya, Bishop Emmanuel Ande, and Rev. Eli Yaku—who filed the suit on behalf of themselves and other members of the UMCN.

They named the Corporate Affairs Commission, the Incorporated Trustees of the Global Methodist Church in Nigeria, and Zenith Bank Plc as first to third defendants, respectively.

The dispute arose after the CAC approved a name change allegedly initiated by a breakaway faction within the church, which identified itself as the Global Methodist Church in Nigeria. However, the plaintiffs challenged the decision, arguing that it breached both statutory provisions and the church’s internal governance framework.

Through their counsel, Chinedu Udora, the plaintiffs sought multiple reliefs, including a determination of whether the application for the name change complied with the church’s constitution. Specifically, they referenced key provisions, including the supremacy clause and several governing articles.

In his ruling, Justice Egwuatu granted all the reliefs sought by the plaintiffs. However, he made no order as to costs.

Earlier in the proceedings, the court dismissed a motion by the CAC seeking to halt the delivery of judgment. The judge agreed with the plaintiffs’ counsel that the court had become functus officio and could not entertain further filings on a matter already concluded and reserved for judgment. He subsequently described the application as an abuse of court process.

Reacting to the judgment, the Presiding Bishop of the United Methodist Church in Nigeria, Cameroon, and Senegal, Emmanuel Ande, described the ruling as a victory for the rule of law and due process.

Nevertheless, he cautioned against celebration, urging reconciliation among members of the divided church.

“This is not a judgment to celebrate. From the beginning, the church should not have been in court,” he said.

While extending an olive branch to members of the breakaway faction, Ande emphasised the need for unity and mutual respect.

“We are Christians, and we must build a united church. The United Methodist Church remains their home if they choose to return,” he added.

At the same time, he advised those who wish to continue as a separate denomination to do so in accordance with the laws of the land.

With the ruling, the court has effectively restored the legal identity and structure of the United Methodist Church in Nigeria, while also reinforcing the importance of due process in organisational governance.

You may also like

Leave a Comment

error: Content is protected !!