Proceedings in the trial of former Minister of Power and Steel, Olu Agunloye, took a dramatic turn on Monday after a prosecution witness contradicted part of his earlier testimony under cross-examination before a High Court of the Federal Capital Territory in Apo, Abuja.
The witness, Mr. Iliya Iyakwari, who serves as the fifth prosecution witness (PW5), testified in the ongoing case involving alleged irregularities surrounding the $6 billion Mambilla Hydroelectric Power Project.
During cross-examination, defence counsel, Adeola Adedipe (SAN), sought permission to confront the witness with a document already admitted as evidence. According to the defence, the document contained extracts from a Federal Executive Council (FEC) meeting.
Adedipe asked Iyakwari to confirm when he certified the document. However, the witness told the court that he did not certify it in June 2023 and insisted that no such date appeared on the document.
Following the response, the defence lawyer questioned the accuracy of the witness’s earlier testimony.
“So your evidence to this court that you certified it in June 2023 is not true?” Adedipe asked.
Prosecution Object
The prosecution, led by Abba Mohammed (SAN), immediately objected to the question.
Mohammed argued that the defence based its line of questioning on an exhibit recently tendered and maintained that allowing the question would infringe on the witness’s right to a fair hearing under Section 36 of the Constitution.
However, Adedipe disagreed. He argued that the witness was not a party to the case and therefore could not claim a violation of fair hearing rights.
Furthermore, he maintained that cross-examination exists to test the credibility, accuracy and reliability of a witness’s testimony.
The senior lawyer reminded the court that the witness had earlier confirmed certifying the documents in 2023 before forwarding them to the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC).
“It was as a result of the affirmative response that I asked him to show the court the date he certified it in June 2023, and he said it was not there,” Adedipe told the court.
Court Overrules Objection
In a brief ruling, Justice Jude Onwuegbuzie dismissed the prosecution’s objection and directed the witness to answer the question.
When asked whether his earlier claim that he certified the document in 2023 was untrue, the witness answered in the affirmative, effectively contradicting his previous testimony.
Consequently, the judge adjourned the matter until Wednesday for the continuation of trial.
Background to the Case
Iyakwari had earlier testified that he serves as an Assistant Director (Legal) in the Federal Ministry of Justice and currently works as an Assistant Legal Adviser in the Federal Ministry of Power.
According to him, the EFCC wrote to the Ministry of Power in June 2023 requesting extracts from a Federal Executive Council meeting held on May 31, 2003.
He stated that the ministry’s legal department subsequently obtained the documents, certified them and forwarded certified true copies to the anti-graft agency.
Charges Against Agunloye
The EFCC is prosecuting Agunloye on a seven-count amended charge bordering on alleged disobedience of presidential directives, conspiracy, forgery and gratification-related offences.
Prosecutors allege that the former minister received more than N5 million in 2019 from Leno Adesanya of Sunrise Power and Transmission Company Limited through an intermediary, Jide Sotirin.
The commission further alleges that the payment passed through Agunloye’s Guaranty Trust Bank account as compensation for conveying Federal Government approval for the Mambilla Hydroelectric Power Station project.
Additionally, the EFCC claims that Agunloye conspired with Adesanya to forge a document relating to the construction of the 3,960MW Mambilla Hydroelectric Power Station under a Build, Operate and Transfer arrangement.
Agunloye has denied all allegations and pleaded not guilty to the charges.