The National Association of Nigerian Youth in Development (NANYD) has questioned a recommendation to overhaul the leadership of the Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps (NSCDC) following the deaths of 33 miners in Minna, Niger State, arguing that it contradicts the findings of the committee that investigated the incident.
The association commended the federal government’s probe committee for submitting its report but faulted its recommendation to restructure the Corps’ leadership, describing the move as a potential witch-hunt.
In a statement signed by its National President, Alhaji Bukura Ahmed, PhD, NANYD said the report’s executive summary indicated that the suspended Niger State commandant conducted the operation without the requisite approval and did not inform the NSCDC national leadership.
According to the association, the finding raises questions about the recommendation to overhaul the national leadership when, it argued, the operation was conducted without its knowledge or involvement.
“The same report that recommends a total overhaul and restructuring of the NSCDC leadership also finds in its own words that the arrest operation was carried out without the requisite approval from NSCDC National Headquarters,” Bukura said.
He argued that the operation was planned and executed at the state command level without the involvement of the Corps’ national and zonal leadership or the relevant mining authorities.
Bukura maintained that the national leadership would ordinarily have been expected to investigate the suspects, coordinate intelligence, advise on operational procedures and involve other security agencies where necessary.
He said the suspended commandant had exercised operational discretion without following established channels, with catastrophic consequences.
“If the report’s own findings are true, then the National Headquarters is not the architect of this tragedy. It is a victim of its own subordinates,” he said.
NANYD Questions Accountability
The association argued that the probe committee should have placed greater emphasis on the responsibilities of officers who planned and executed the operation.
Bukura questioned why the committee would recommend an overhaul of the national leadership while also finding that the operation was conducted without the required approval.
He also questioned the accountability of officers at the Niger State command who allegedly failed to follow established procedures.
“What of the Niger command that failed to consult the proper channel before mounting such an operation? What of the officers who planned the raid, who crammed fifty human beings into a cell, who ignored their cries for help?” he asked.
Bukura said the report’s recommendation of murder charges against the officers involved was appropriate but argued that the recommendation to overhaul the national leadership was inconsistent with the findings presented.
His remarks reflect NANYD’s interpretation of the report. The association’s position does not, on its own, establish whether the national leadership bears any institutional or supervisory responsibility for the incident.
Association Defends NSCDC Commandant-General
Bukura also defended the Commandant-General of the NSCDC, Professor Ahmed Abubakar Audi, praising his leadership and the agency’s work over the years.
He opposed calls for Audi’s removal, alleging that powerful interests within the government were using the tragedy to undermine the Corps’ leadership.
To support his argument, he questioned whether similar calls for leadership overhauls would follow security-related killings in Benue and Plateau states and other parts of the country.
He argued that removing the national leadership over an operation allegedly conducted without its knowledge would amount to collective punishment for the actions of subordinate officers.
“Leadership is not a tea party,” Bukura said, insisting that the leadership should not bear the full blame for what he described as an individual officer’s failure to perform his duties diligently.
NANYD Alleges Witch-Hunt
The association maintained that the recommendation to overhaul the NSCDC leadership appeared inconsistent with the report’s findings and called for the reasoning behind the recommendation to be examined.
Bukura also questioned whether the Corps’ previous security operations and achievements had received comparable attention.
He argued that the committee’s findings and recommendations should be consistent, particularly when determining responsibility for the miners’ deaths.
“The motive behind a recommendation that contradicts the findings that precede it deserves to be unravelled as thoroughly as the deaths themselves,” he said.
NANYD’s criticism centres on whether the committee adequately distinguished between the officers who allegedly planned and carried out the operation and the national leadership, which the association says was not informed.
The committee’s full report and the evidence supporting its recommendations remain central to determining the extent of responsibility at the state command and national levels.